ETags vs Last-Modified: Comparing Web Cache Validation Methods

URL Magazine

Web caching is an important part of improving website performance, as it allows the server to deliver webpages quickly by storing copies of the recently requested content. To ensure that users are receiving up-to-date versions of a webpage, websites must use certain cache validation methods such as ETags and Last-Modified headers. An ETag (Entity Tag) is an HTTP header containing unique values which identify specific versions of a given resource on a website; these values are generated based on the content contained in each page or resource. The Last-Modified header provides information about when a particular version of the page was last modified; this value can be used to determine if any updates have been made since the user's last request for that page. Both ETags and Last-Modified serve as effective tools for confirming whether or not cached resources need updating, ensuring that users always receive accurate content from your website servers.


image

What is an ETag?

An ETag (Entity Tag) is an HTTP header containing a unique value that identifies a specific version of a given resource on a website. An ETag can be used to validate cached resources, as it allows web servers to compare versions of the same page and determine if any updates have been made since the user's last request for that page. A server can generate an ETag by computing a hash based on the content contained in each page or resource.

When using ETags, web browsers send requests with If-None-Match headers which contain previously received ETags from previous requests; these values are compared against new ones generated by the server to check for changes between versions. If there is no difference between them, then the browser will use its cached copy instead of requesting new data from the server. This helps save time and bandwidth as well as reduce latency issues caused by unnecessary new requests being sent out from users' devices.

The benefits offered by using ETags include improved performance due to reduced network traffic, increased security because only valid copies are exchanged between clients and servers, better scalability through distributed caching capabilities across multiple locations/devices and easier debugging when troubleshooting problems related to web applications or pages loading incorrectly due to outdated caches. All in all, utilizing this protocol has proven itself invaluable when it comes to providing users with up-to-date information while also allowing sites to perform more efficiently thanks to its caching capabilities


image

What is Last-Modified?

Last-Modified is an HTTP header which provides information about when a particular version of the page was last modified. This value can be used to determine if any updates have been made since the user's last request for that page, allowing web servers to compare versions and confirm whether or not cached resources need updating. Last-Modified headers are sent out by web browsers with each request, containing details such as the date and time of modification as well as other pertinent information regarding the resource in question.

Advantages of using Last-Modified include improved performance due to reduced network traffic; this is because new requests will only be sent out if there has been an update on the requested resource since it was last accessed. Additionally, utilizing this protocol ensures that users always receive accurate content from your website servers, providing better security than simply relying on caching alone. It also makes debugging easier when troubleshooting problems related to web applications or pages loading incorrectly due to outdated caches; developers can quickly identify what changes were recently made and why they may have caused issues with certain elements not displaying properly. Finally, Last-Modified helps improve scalability across multiple locations/devices through distributed caching capabilities - meaning websites can deliver more up-to-date data without having to constantly generate new copies for every single device accessing them simultaneously.

Comparing ETag vs Last-Modified

Both ETags and Last-Modified serve as effective tools for validating caches, ensuring that users always receive accurate content from your website servers. However, there are some drawbacks to both methods which should be taken into account when deciding which one will best suit the needs of your site.

Last-Modified is not a very efficient protocol if used improperly; this is because it requires web browsers to send requests with If-None-Match headers containing previously received Last-Modified values with each request in order to compare versions and determine if any updates have been made since the user's last request for that page. This can lead to increased network traffic due to unnecessary new requests being sent out from users' devices - thus reducing the overall performance of your website. Additionally, scalability across multiple locations/devices may be hindered by using this method as it does not support distributed caching capabilities as well as other protocols do.


image

On the other hand, ETag offers improved performance due to reduced network traffic; this is because only valid copies are exchanged between clients and servers (i.e. no unnecessary new requests). It also provides better security than simply relying on caching alone; developers can quickly identify what changes were recently made and why they may have caused issues with certain elements not displaying properly thanks to its ability to generate unique identifiers based on the content contained within each page or resource. Finally, utilizing this protocol allows websites to take advantage of distributed caching capabilities - meaning more up-to-date data can be delivered without having constantly generate new copies for every single device accessing them simultaneously - thereby increasing scalability across multiple locations/devices.

Conclusion

The cost of implementing both ETags and Last-Modified depends on the type of website being developed. For basic websites, the costs are relatively low since these protocols can be implemented without having to buy any extra software or hardware. However, for more complex sites that require specific caching requirements, additional costs may be incurred in order to purchase specialized tools and services which support these protocols. Additionally, there will likely be an increased amount of time needed to set up and configure both ETags and Last-Modified properly so they work correctly with all parts of the website.

When deciding between using ETag or Last-Modified it is important to consider your site's specific needs as well as its intended usage patterns (e.g. how often content changes). If your website requires frequent updates but does not need distributed caching capabilities across multiple locations/devices then Last-Modified would most likely make sense due to its ability to quickly compare versions without needing extra requests from users' devices; however, if you want improved scalability via distributed caching abilities then utilizing an ETag protocol could provide a better solution as it allows web servers generate unique identifiers based off of content contained within each page or resource which supports this capability much better than a single timestamp value (i. e., last modified date) would do. Ultimately it comes down to what kind of features you need while at the same time ensuring that users always receive accurate data from your website servers - making sure cached resources are updated appropriately when necessary by implementing either one or both options depending on what best fits your project's requirements


If you wish to contribute to our blog, please email us on morhadotsan@gmail.com.

URL Magazine

Popular Articles