Legal Considerations in Stock Option Exercise: Protecting Your Interests

URL Magazine

Many employees are unsure of how stock options function without a well-thought-out strategy. Study shows, 69% of workers believe their employer must explain how their equity functions, yet only 37% of workers' employers offer sufficient equity education.

Stock option exercise provides you the legal right to purchase shares of the company's stock at a certain price specified in your option grant. When you get your options, the strike price is often the same as the shares' FMV (fair market value).

Every employee stock option has an expiration date, which means you have a certain amount of time to take action. You should always make thoughtful decisions, regardless of whether you decide to use your stock options. Here's how you handle the legal considerations that accompany employee stock option management.


Stock Option Exercise: Legal Considerations

Knowing what kind of options you've got and the various legal considerations associated with each before exercising stock options is important.


Terms and Conditions

Carefully read the terms and conditions in your stock option agreement before exercising your options. Comprehending the vesting schedule, exercise window, and any company-imposed restrictions is imperative. There can be legal ramifications if you don't follow these terms.

Let’s assume you received 1,000 stock options with a one-year cliff and a four-year vesting term. It implies that options vest progressively over the following three years, beginning after you have worked for the organization for at least one year. If the award is for 10 years, then that's the exercise window. You risk losing part or all of your options if you quit the firm before the one-year cliff or don't exercise them within the given window.


Tax Implications

Consider the potential tax consequences of your stock option exercise. Option exercises may result in taxable events in some countries. You should talk to a tax expert to know your tax responsibilities and how to reduce them.

Imagine you have options that you can exercise at $20 per share, but the market price is $50 per share when you opt to exercise it. There is a taxable gain of $30 per share. Depending on your jurisdiction, this gain may be liable to rates on ordinary income tax, capital gains tax, or both.


Securities Law Compliance

When a business goes public, its stock option exercise must comply with securities rules, following all applicable rules and regulations to stay out of legal issues. Careful adherence to the guidelines provided by companies about compliance with these rules is essential. These laws regulate the offer and sale of securities, including stock options. Failure to comply with these laws may lead to civil or criminal penalties.

Suppose you work for a publicly traded company and decide to exercise your stock options. In that case, you may need to comply with securities laws, such as the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.


Exercising Stock Options to Safeguard Employee Rights

While you can use your options from the moment they vest until they expire, there are a few things to remember to safeguard employee rights.


Value of stock options

With the current price being more than the option's exercise price, you can immediately sell some or all of your shares for a guaranteed profit, which could be the only rational choice.

For example, your exercise rate is $5, and the stock rate is $10. The immediate exercise and sale of your options will result in a profit of $5 per share ($10 minus $5). Using the profit, you can avoid paying out-of-pocket for the exercise expenditures (such as the exercise price, tax, fees, etc.).



Instead of selling your private firm stock options on a stock market for profit, you'll need to utilize your cash to exercise them. Purchasing shares with funds that could never become liquid might also be risky.


Financial standing

Exercising and selling your stock options immediately can help you pay off debt, launch a business, buy a car, and other financial goals if you need money now.

Additionally, a lot of financial experts suggest having a diverse portfolio. So, to diversify your portfolio, you can sell your shares if you own over 10-15% of your company's stock (not over 15 to 20% overall).


Legal Pitfalls to Consider and Avoid

Options grants motivate US startup workers, consultants, and advisers, but many minor pitfalls can cause legal and tax concerns that are difficult and expensive to correct.


Ignoring special clauses in Board approval

The Board of Directors of your firm must expressly authorize the option grant in order for any unusual provisions, such as an accelerated vesting period, to be included. In addition to referencing these provisions the Board must adopt acceleration or other special terms, ideally alongside the option grant.

In order to save time and avoid confusion, it is wise to inform your legal counsel of any specific conditions in relation to their option grants. Always Consult with your legal counsel before making any written promises in order to avoid any mistakes or inconsistencies.


ISO violations

The US tax system favors incentive stock options (ISOs). ISO treatment is available for several option grants to US taxpayer employees who meet the rules.

Companies often make the mistake of not noticing the extra rules that apply when the person receiving the ISO owns more than 10% of the voting rights of all classes of business stock at option grants. Option grants to 10% of owners qualify as ISOs when:

- During the grant, the exercise price is 110% of the FMV.

- The term should be under 5 years from the grant date.

The ISO rules also limit the number of choices that can be made by ISOs based on their worth (as of the grant date) and their exercise times in a given year. Companies can cross this threshold with significant or early exercisable option awards.

Before getting option grants approved, make sure you and your attorney have reviewed the basic requirements for ISO treatment and have reviewed the option terms.


Disregarding US securities laws

Stock options are securities under US law. Thus, you must follow state and federal securities regulations. Notify your legal counsel of any suggested option grants, such as the option's states of residence, the number of shares included in these grants, and the current FMV. They will review federal and relevant state securities legislation requirements and guide you before the Board approves them.


Safeguarding Your Future through Informed Stock Option Exercise

There isn't always a clear-cut way for employees to cash in on their stock option exercise. Yet, it's also possible to have a good time with it. To get the specifics of an option, you'll need to sign a contract with the relevant business. You should read the conditions of your contract carefully. The document will lay out the details, including the number of options being granted and the duration of the vesting schedule. After all, you worked diligently to acquire your vested options on stocks, and the thought of using them to make more money should make you excited. 

If you wish to contribute to our blog, please email us on

URL Magazine

Popular Articles